2009 BMW 3-Series
2009 BMW 3-Series Review
Review Last Updated: 7/23/12
Used Car Scores
Critics’ Rating: 9.8
Operating Cost: 6.7
How we calculate scores
Research analyzed for this review
Pros and Cons
Smooth manual transmission
Sporty, composed handling
Refined engine options
Finicky iDrive system
Poor reliability rating
Research Other Years
2013 BMW 3-Series
2012 BMW 3-Series
2011 BMW 3-Series
2010 BMW 3-Series
2008 BMW 3-Series
2007 BMW 3-Series
The 2009 BMW 3-Series is highly acclaimed for its smooth engine options and agile suspension. It lacks the strong reliability of competing 2009 midsize cars and doesn’t have the roomiest back seat or trunk, but the 3-Series is a good choice if performance is your top priority.
The 2009 BMW 3-Series is ranked:
#20 in Used Upscale Midsize Cars under $25K
#10 in 2009 Upscale Midsize Cars
When it was new, critics said the 3-Series has a blend of performance and refinement that few competitors can match. Its available engines and transmissions, they said, are some of the smoothest available, and combine with its athletic suspension to make it one of the most compelling sport sedans available. Its main drawback is its low reliability score and projected costly repairs. The 3-Series is available in sedan, coupe and retractable hardtop convertible body styles, as well as a sport wagon and high-performance M3.
The rear-wheel drive 3-Series comes with three engines that distinguish trim levels. The base 328i has a 3.0-liter inline six-cylinder engine that makes 230 horsepower, while the 335i adds a turbocharger to the mix, raising the output to 300 horsepower. A turbodiesel-powered 335d is also available, which generates 265 horsepower and substantially more torque than its gas-powered siblings. You can select from a manual or automatic transmission on gas models, and many critics said that BMW makes some of the best manual gearboxes in the industry. The 328i sedan nets 18/28 mpg city/highway with either transmission, which is about average for the class. Opting for all-wheel drive or the more potent 335i drops fuel economy slightly. The 335d averages 23/36 mpg.
Inside, critics praised the 3-Series for its straightforward, high-quality cabin. Reviewers said the seats are very comfortable and supportive, although most said the rear seats could benefit from additional legroom. Maximum trunk space is 12 cubic feet, which is about average for the 3-Series’ closest competitors, but below that of other 2009 midsize cars. Bear in mind that the convertible’s retractable hardtop is stowed in the trunk, which cuts down on trunk space when the top is lowered. Standard equipment includes automatic climate control, a sunroof and a 10-speaker stereo. Option packages and upper trims add leather seats, rear parking sensors and navigation with BMW’s iDrive system, which most critics found difficult to use.
See the full 2009 BMW 3-Series specs »
[Angular Front] [Angular Rear] [Side View] [Front View] See More Photos »
Other Cars to Consider
A worthy alternative to the 2009 BMW 3-series is the 2009 Infiniti G. With a powerful engine and sport-tuned suspension, critics said the G37 is one of the closest-matched rivals to the 3-Series. Like the 3-series, the G37 is available in coupe, sedan and hardtop convertible body styles.
Other 2009 midsize cars worth considering are the 2009 Audi A4 and A5. Critics said the A4 sedan and A5 coupe have agile, refined handling and a high-quality, upscale interior. While they deliver ample power, most critics didn’t find their engines as potent and smooth as those from BMW. However, both the A4 and A5 offer slightly better reliability ratings, and the A4 earns a better safety score as well.